MAT291: Lecture 26 - Stokes’ Theorem tooling Examples
Overview
Parinaz Naseri demonstrates how Stokes’ theorem turns a difficult flux integral of curl into a simpler boundary circulation, first using a wavy parametrized surface whose four boundary segments yield a circulation of 6. A second example shows why the theorem requires the curl to be defined across the chosen surface: the field (-y/(x²+y²), x/(x²+y²), 0) has zero curl off the z-axis but circulation 2π around the unit circle, which is resolved by excluding the singular axis and respecting inner-boundary orientation.
Key takeaways
- When multiple surfaces share a boundary, Stokes’ theorem permits choosing the one with the simplest geometry; a flat disk can be far easier than a curved hemisphere.
- For a parametrized surface over 0≤u,v≤1, its boundary comes from setting each parameter to 0 or 1, and the four resulting edges must be traversed with consistent orientation.
- For the wavy surface r(u,v)=(2u+v,u+2v,sin(πu)sin(πv)), the boundary lies in z=0 and the circulation of F=(-y,x,0) totals 6.
- The field F=(-y/(x²+y²),x/(x²+y²),0) has curl zero away from the z-axis but circulation 2π around the unit circle, so a spanning disk crossing the axis violates Stokes’ theorem’s hypotheses.
- On an annulus excluding the origin, the outer circulation 2π and inner circulation -2π cancel, consistent with the zero curl over that nonsingular surface.
- Boundary orientation is essential: for a hole viewed from above, the outer edge is counterclockwise and the inner edge clockwise under the same surface-normal convention.
Chapters
- Stokes’ theorem equates circulation around a closed curve with flux of curl through any compatible spanning surface.
- Interior circulations cancel, leaving the contribution along the boundary curve.
- For a circular boundary, a flat disk is often simpler than a hemisphere; for a triangular boundary, one planar triangle may be easier than three coordinate-plane pieces.
- The surface is parametrized over 0 ≤ u,v ≤ 1 by r(u,v) = (2u+v, u+2v, sin(πu)sin(πv)).
- The surface rises and dips internally, but its edges lie in the z=0 plane because one parameter is 0 or 1 along each edge.
- The exercise asks for flux of curl F without a surface integral, directing the calculation toward the boundary circulation.
- Set v=0 to obtain r(u,0)=(2u,u,0), and set u=1 to obtain r(1,v)=(2+v,1+2v,0).
- The remaining edges are r(u,1)=(2u+1,u+2,0) and r(0,v)=(v,2v,0).
- The four parameter directions must connect consecutively around the boundary; the return edges use reversed orientation and a minus sign.
- On the boundary, z=0, so the field reduces to F=(-y,x,0), avoiding substitution of the interior surface’s sinusoidal z-coordinate.
- Use the edge derivatives (2,1,0) for u-directed sides and (1,2,0) for v-directed sides.
- Evaluate F(r)·r′ on each segment separately because x and y have different parameterizations on all four edges.
- The first and fourth edge integrands vanish after taking the dot product.
- The second and third edges each contribute 3, giving total circulation 3+3=6.
- The example shows how Stokes’ theorem avoids a more cumbersome surface integral involving curl F, rᵤ×rᵥ, and trigonometric terms.
- Stokes’ theorem cannot be applied if curl F is undefined anywhere on the chosen surface.
- The example field F=(-y/(x²+y²), x/(x²+y²), 0) is undefined on the z-axis, where x=y=0.
- A disk spanning a curve around the z-axis includes the singularity, so direct circulation and disk flux need not agree under an invalid application.
- Parametrize the counterclockwise unit circle by r(t)=(cos t,sin t,0), with 0≤t≤2π.
- Along the circle, F(r(t))=(-sin t,cos t,0), which equals r′(t).
- The dot product is 1 throughout, so the direct circulation is ∫₀²π 1 dt=2π.
- Because F has only x- and y-components, its curl points in the z-direction.
- Differentiating the rational components gives curl F=0 wherever x²+y²≠0.
- The curl is still undefined when x=y=0, so the z-axis remains excluded even though the curl vanishes elsewhere.
- The unit disk intersects the z-axis at the origin, where curl F is undefined; treating its flux as zero would incorrectly contradict the 2π circulation.
- Removing the origin creates an annular surface where curl F is defined and zero throughout.
- The outer boundary contributes 2π and the clockwise inner boundary contributes -2π, so the total boundary circulation is zero, matching the curl flux.
- In polar coordinates, the field is F=θ̂/r, the gradient of the angle θ away from the origin.
- On radial segments, the tangent is parallel to r̂ and perpendicular to θ̂, so those segments contribute zero circulation.
- For the illustrated contour that does not wind around the origin, the two angular portions cancel; the unit circle’s nonzero 2π circulation comes from enclosing the singularity.
- For a surface with a hole, the right-hand-rule-compatible orientation is counterclockwise on the outer boundary and clockwise on the inner boundary when viewed from above.
- The post-lecture discussion reinforces that Stokes’ theorem is not false at the singularity; it is simply inapplicable to a surface or boundary that includes the z-axis.
- Naseri notes that students may use different valid techniques, including parameterization, implicit descriptions, and spherical coordinates, and may choose any correct method on the exam.
Transcript excerpt
0:01 Good morning everyone. Okay. So um let's start with some examples in the Stoke theorem before we leave the fundamental theorems we learned. Okay. So here um you know what the Stoke theorem would say? A so theorem would say that the circulation over a closed curve is equal to the flux of the curl leaving a surface. What surface? Any surface that that closed curve could enclose. Okay. And the reason for that was that these internal circulations would cancel each other out and what is left is just
0:50 on the what is on the boundary. Okay, we learned that through an example yesterday. We learned that the wise thing to do is to in order to calculate the circulation if we are going through the surface integral of the flux of the curve is to choose the easier surface. Remember with the hemisphere and the flat disc obviously a flat disc is easier when the curved circle um when the curve is a circle. Here, for example, if you're dealing with a tetraedron um surface and a triangle that is enclosing that, you have two choices for the surface of to calculate the flux of
1:41 the curve. One is the slanted plane, a slanted triangle that you see on the left and um you can calculate the flux of the integral through that slanted one or you also have another surface which is composed of the three coordinate planes with the xhat, yhat and z hat uh pointing internally. Finally uh that [clears throat] surface is composed of actually three coordinate planes. You could actually do that um the surface integral on that one too, but it would just take you longer, right? So here we always say even if the question gives you a crazy or crazy
This is the start of the transcript. Save this video free for the whole transcript, searchable and time-coded.
In this course
Related notes
Summary, takeaways, and chapters were generated by AI from the video's transcript and may contain errors. The video belongs to its creator, Parinaz Naseri.