Introduction to Philosophy: Clouds, lecture 1
Watch on YouTube →
Overview
Abraham Stone places Aristophanes' The Clouds, probably first performed in 423 BC, alongside Plato's later depictions of Socrates and argues that their differences cannot be read as straightforward factual disagreement: comic caricature shapes Aristophanes' portrayal, while occasional similarities suggest the historical Socrates may have resembled Plato's questioning figure. Stone reads the play's satire as targeting mistaken ideas about education, natural science, religion, and the corruption of youth, especially Strepsiades' attempt to blame Socrates for problems caused by his own choices.
Key takeaways
- The Clouds predates Socrates' trial by 24 years, and Plato was about five when it was first performed, so the play is the earliest surviving source discussed for Socrates, not a response to Plato.
- Aristophanes' Socrates differs sharply from Plato's in setting, students, secrecy, and claimed expertise, but comic genre makes those differences unreliable as a simple record of the historical Socrates.
- The play's echoes of Socratic questioning, including teaching an interlocutor from his own answers, may preserve recognizable features of Socrates beneath the caricature.
- Strepsiades seeks rhetoric to evade debts he knowingly incurred, so Aristophanes can ridicule accusations that Socrates corrupted him by showing that his dishonesty came first.
- Strepsiades' shifting claims about gods, oaths, and memory show that religious belief does not reliably make him moral; he invokes divine punishment when it serves his interests and ignores it when payment is due.
Chapters
- Aristophanes was a comic playwright, and Athenian theater began as part of worship associated with Dionysus.
- The Clouds is generally dated to the City Dionysia of 423 BC, though the play's references suggest it may have been revised after its first performance.
- The chorus sometimes addresses the audience on Aristophanes' behalf, including a complaint that the play did not win a prize.
- Socrates was tried and executed in 399 BC, 24 years after the proposed first performance of The Clouds.
- Plato was born around 428 BC and was about five years old in 423 BC, so he likely encountered the play later rather than at its first performance.
- The Apology is set in 399 BC, while Plato wrote it after Socrates' death; apparent echoes of The Clouds therefore cannot show Aristophanes imitating Plato.
- At line 247, Socrates says the gods are not nomisma for the Thinkery, a phrase that can suggest both belief and money or coinage.
- Strepsiades misreads the line as a reference to coins, illustrating the Greek word's ambiguity.
- The related verb appears in the charge that Socrates does not believe in the gods, raising the possibility of an echo, a shared formula, or an allusion to accusations against Anaxagoras.
- Plato's Apology nearly explicitly identifies Aristophanes as an old accuser through Socrates' reference to a comic poet.
- Aristophanes' Socrates teaches inside the Thinkery and decides which pupils to admit; Plato's Socrates typically approaches people in public and questions them.
- Stone frames the comparison around how Plato may deliberately distinguish his Socrates from the comic character.
- Strepsiades describes the Thinkery as a place where teachers take money, while a translator's note argues Socrates shows little interest in payment.
- The play's ending suggests Strepsiades will bring Socrates material benefits, and the school's poverty does not by itself disprove paid teaching.
- The invented word Thinkery makes the school sound like a bakery for producing thoughts, turning intellectual instruction into a comic commercial trade.
- A student says it is not sanctioned to reveal certain thoughts to outsiders, using language associated with customary law or divine decree.
- The students call their teachings mysteries, invoking Greek religious rites whose knowledge was reserved for initiates.
- The Thinkery's secrecy and initiation rituals contrast with Plato's Socrates, who shares arguments openly in public dialogues such as the Meno.
- Aristophanes' Socrates claims specialized knowledge about phenomena such as thunder and the buzzing of gnats, unlike the Socrates of the Ion and Euthyphro.
- He also appears to have special knowledge about the gods and to teach persuasive speaking that can help Strepsiades escape debt.
- Stone cautions that the comic character's knowledge and methods should not be treated as a direct portrait of the historical Socrates.
- Stone compares The Clouds to South Park: familiar public figures are exaggerated or depicted in deliberately absurd ways rather than accurately represented.
- Athenian jokes about sexual roles and status relied on local conventions, including the disgrace attached to an adult freeborn man being sexually passive.
- The play's crude humor, including wordplay about bodily functions, can carry sophisticated satire rather than simply offering literal information about Socrates.
- At line 345, Socrates tells Strepsiades to answer whatever he asks, introducing a question-and-answer exchange reminiscent of Platonic dialogue.
- At line 385, Socrates says he will teach Strepsiades from himself, an idea that resembles Socratic questioning even though the comic lesson explains thunder through digestion.
- The contrast between the serious dialogic form and the absurd subject matter suggests Aristophanes may be parodying recognizable Socratic teaching practices.
- Plato's Socrates compares his philosophical work to his mother's midwifery: he helps others bring out ideas they already have.
- In The Clouds, the claim that Strepsiades can discover an explanation within himself becomes a joke about bringing forth a fart.
- Stone argues that such parallels may preserve something about Socrates' questioning style beneath the comic distortion.
- The Clouds also has Socrates tell Strepsiades to discover and state what he wishes, a phrase that resembles Plato's emphasis on an interlocutor's own answers.
- Similarities in the play may point toward the historical Socrates, especially the questioning figure in Plato's early or Socratic dialogues.
- Because comedy and philosophical dialogue have different purposes, differences between Aristophanes and Plato do not automatically prove that they disagree about Socrates.
- Plato presents Socrates as a teacher, but his portrayal need not be free of criticism; Plato himself founded a school that selected students.
- Stone compares political caricatures, including a New Yorker cover depicting Barack and Michelle Obama as militants, to show how ridicule can target public accusations rather than its subjects.
- The South Park movie's blame-Canada plot similarly mocks adults who blame Terrance and Phillip for children's behavior instead of examining their own role.
- Strepsiades attributes his financial troubles to causes including the lunar calendar, his son Pheidippides' horse expenses, the war, and Socrates.
- His interest payments come due at the end of the lunar month, leading him to treat the waning moon as if it were responsible for his debt.
- Socrates points out that Strepsiades became indebted through his own choices; Pheidippides and outside forces do not erase that responsibility.
- Strepsiades wants instruction in the weaker speech, which he misunderstands as a magical technique that guarantees victory even when he owes the money.
- The phrase refers to making a worse argument defeat a better one, a reputation commonly attached to sophistic rhetoric.
- Strepsiades imagines natural science can solve his debt by having a Thessalian witch pull the moon into a well so the month never ends.
- Socrates' natural explanations suggest that phenomena attributed to gods, such as rain and thunder, have physical causes.
- The Clouds are presented as divine characters, but their practical benefits are explained through rain and water rather than supernatural power.
- Socrates' opening claim that he looks down on the sun can mean either looking at it or studying it, connecting natural inquiry with skepticism about traditional gods.
- Strepsiades swears by the gods that he will pay Socrates, then seeks instruction in the speech that lets him pay nothing back.
- When asked whether he has a good memory, he says he remembers debts owed to him but forgets debts he owes.
- Socrates' arguments about rain and Zeus or lightning and perjury prompt Strepsiades to say he had never considered obvious counterexamples, exposing selective rather than newly created disbelief.
- Stone argues that Strepsiades is already morally compromised when he seeks help cheating creditors, so Socrates cannot be the original cause of his dishonesty.
- The Thinkery's pupils are portrayed as pale, shoeless, and unhappy, making them unlikely role models for the fashionable, horse-loving Pheidippides.
- The play's final satire targets people who fear that education will corrupt youth while overlooking their own influence and responsibility; Stone leaves comparison with Aristophanes' self-portrait for the next lecture.
Transcript excerpt
0:02 Okay. Hello. Um, so again, unless there are any questions about anything. Okay. So, I see a disadvantage of this is I can't see anyone in the audience. Yeah, that's better. Um, I'll just start talking about the clouds. Um, okay. Um, I guess I should say something about Aristophanes, but I don't know much about him. Uh, not even sure what his dates are.
0:50 Um but um he's actually a character in one of Plato's dialogues. Uh but in any case, obviously he was a comic playwright. Um and uh um so comedies were uh theater in general was part of the worship of Dianisis like that's kind of how it started. Um, so, uh, this this play, The Clouds, was now I'm not sure how we know this date. Um,
1:38 uh, but supposedly it was it was performed at the city Dionicia in 423 BC. So um black. So the Dionia was a festival in honor of Dionis. Obviously Dianisis is the god of wine and um other related things. Um so uh 423 BC this this is when we think it was it was produc or at least first produced.
2:29 Um there's uh and you know there's a footnote in the in the West and West translation that like somewhat goes into the question of of inconsistent indications of the date of the play. So I mean I think that's well no it's not just that it's because it see it sounds like when the chorus starts addressing the audience and at least at first but I think actually even later too the chorus is speaking for Aristophanes directly. So the chorus is like speaking to the audience on behalf of the playwright and it says something like um you know I was upset because my play didn't win the
This is the start of the transcript. Save this video free for the whole transcript, searchable and time-coded.
In this course
Related notes
Summary, takeaways, and chapters were generated by AI from the video's transcript and may contain errors. The video belongs to its creator, Abraham Stone.