A Live Experiment in Empathy with Basim Razzo | The Uncounted | 18SP Class #25 Full Lecture
Overview
Sam Richards and Basim Razzo use Razzo’s experience of losing his wife, daughter, brother, and nephew in a U.S.-led airstrike to make empathy concrete: understanding another person’s perspective can interrupt fear and collective blame. Razzo recounts his family’s life in Mosul, the strike and its aftermath, the U.S. military’s admission of faulty intelligence and rejected $15,000 payment, and why he chooses not to hate ordinary Americans; the class connects his account to personal responsibility, faith, and learning beyond national stereotypes.
Key takeaways
- Razzo’s case shows how faulty intelligence can turn a misidentified civilian home into a lethal target: the U.S. military acknowledged bombing his family’s houses after labeling them an ISIS facility.
- Razzo rejected the U.S. offer of $15,000 for the deaths of his wife and daughter, arguing that financial payments cannot represent the value of human lives.
- Razzo separates ordinary Americans from government decisions because his eight years in the United States gave him lasting friendships and firsthand experience of public kindness.
- Empathy can affect immediate outcomes: during a 2003 U.S. military detention, Razzo used English and his knowledge of local residents to help release fishermen and farm workers.
- Razzo turns survival and faith into a practical purpose: he hopes that changing 10 students’ perspectives will lead them to influence five more people each.
- Razzo’s account of Mosul’s destroyed Old City shows why war should be understood through civilian lives and physical places, not only through political arguments or entertainment.
Chapters
- Richards opens with a moment of recognition for people whose lives have been upended by war.
- His 2010 talk, “A Radical Experiment in Empathy,” asked Americans to imagine Iraqi civilians’ lives through invasion, sanctions, and war.
- The talk challenged audiences to consider insurgents’ perspectives and whether they might see themselves as patriotic defenders rather than simply violent enemies.
- Razzo first contacted Richards after the TED talk, saying its account of Iraqi views on the invasion and oil matched conversations among his friends.
- The two built a friendship through Skype, photographs, and repeated classroom visits about life in Mosul.
- Richards learned that an airstrike had killed Razzo’s wife Mayada, daughter Tuqa, brother Mohanad, and nephew Najeeb, and destroyed their neighboring homes.
- After a year away from class, Razzo returned to speak about forgiveness, justice, violence, and grief.
- He introduces himself as an Iraqi Arab and Muslim, says he is a friend to everyone, and takes a selfie with the class.
- Richards describes Razzo’s visit as joyful and deeply painful because the friendship is inseparable from the family’s deaths.
- After studying in the United States, Razzo returned to Iraq in 1988, served in the Army Corps of Engineers, and later managed his father’s pharmacies.
- He became Huawei’s account manager for Mosul in 2011, then took responsibility for Kirkuk before the company withdrew after ISIS entered Mosul in 2014.
- Razzo and Mayada had lived in Michigan, where she sold cosmetics and bought him his first SLR camera; they later returned to Iraq and raised Yahya and Tuqa.
- After a night explosion, Razzo woke injured beneath a collapsed ceiling, with a broken foot and injuries to his back and pelvis.
- His sister-in-law had been thrown from the first floor, and the family’s damaged homes left him trapped until neighbors carried him to a Mosul hospital.
- At the hospital, his brother-in-law told him Mayada, Tuqa, Mohanad, and Najeeb had died; Razzo’s son Yahya had survived because he had left Mosul.
- After Richards contacted a former student at the State Department, Razzo assembled photographs, background information, and GPS coordinates for the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad.
- The U.S. military later acknowledged bombing the homes after misidentifying them as an ISIS bomb-manufacturing facility.
- Officials offered Razzo $15,000 for his wife and daughter, which he rejected; he said the usual payment for a civilian death was $2,000.
- Razzo says he does not hate Americans because his eight years in the United States gave him close American friends and showed him that ordinary people were not responsible for the strike.
- He argues that sustained anger consumes a person, while anger about something changeable should lead to action.
- Razzo understands the tragedy through faith in destiny and says surviving his injuries and relearning to walk strengthened his belief that he has a mission.
- Razzo urges students to imagine another person’s feelings before making consequential decisions, saying empathy could prevent many harmful actions.
- In 2003, U.S. soldiers detained about 100 people near his home while investigating a stolen truck; Razzo used English to explain who the local fishermen and farm workers were.
- He recognized that a soldier who had fought in Najaf was frightened, spoke calmly with him, and helped secure the release of people he knew.
- Razzo says he sometimes breaks down and cries but tries to remain strong for his son, nephew, niece, and other relatives as head of the family.
- He finds strength in faith and hopes that changing the minds of 10 students will create a ripple effect as they influence others.
- Razzo describes Mosul’s 500-year-old Old City as devastated by heavy bombardment, with narrow streets, homes, and historic buildings destroyed during the campaign to retake it.
- Razzo says the U.S. dismantled Iraq’s army and civil-government structure, leaving the country in chaos after the invasion.
- He rejects being labeled a terrorist and points out that ISIS harmed Iraqis as well as Americans, Christians, and British people.
- He describes losing his family, home, job, and office building as a direct consequence of war and ISIS’s arrival.
- Razzo advises students not to generalize from a single news source or assume every Arab is a terrorist or every American wants to take Iraqi oil.
- He encourages people to research, travel, and look beyond familiar places and perspectives.
- He points to photographs of Mosul and his own experience as evidence that war’s destruction is not an abstract debate or a video-game spectacle.
- Razzo recalls meeting Maytham, one of the last five Jewish people in Iraq, during his 1988 army service.
- He describes growing up around different religious communities and having close Christian friends who later moved to Florida, Toronto, Los Angeles, and the Gulf.
- His stories challenge the idea that religious identity alone determines whether people can be friends or neighbors.
- A student apologizes for the disrespect of offering $2,000 for a person’s life and asks how Razzo copes with losing his home.
- Razzo says he now rents in Erbil and still does not feel that his mother’s house is truly his home; he cannot afford to rebuild the destroyed house.
- He accepts the student’s apology as an expression of sympathy while emphasizing that Iraqi lives deserve the same human respect as anyone else’s.
- Razzo explains that speaking English helped him connect with U.S. soldiers, while language or another shared point of reference can make strangers more willing to communicate.
- Richards urges students to focus on applying Razzo’s message in their own lives rather than feeling powerless over every global injustice.
- Students thank Razzo for making distant civilian losses personal; he says he is glad if his account has changed their ideas.
Transcript excerpt
0:00 If we, I'd like to begin today with a just a moment in recognition for what we're going to be discussing and in acknowledgement for all the people whose lives have been upended for reasons that we're going to discuss today. So just a moment. So this class begins in 2010 when I did a TED talk
1:11 and the TED talk was called A Radical Experiment in Empathy and I wish I could say I was the one that came up with that title, but it wasn't. It was Laurie and in this talk I walk Americans through the lives of average Iraqi Muslims to give them a sense of what it would be like to go through the wars, the invasion, the sanctions, and all of the things that Iraqis have gone through and it's a very edgy talk because I talk about why we were in Iraq in the first place, which is largely because of oil. Somebody else's resource. It's an edgy talk because I talked about how naturally Iraqis would view this as a Christian invasion, not just an American invasion because we associate America,
2:06 the United States with Christianity and it's an edgy talk because in the end the experiment, the radical experiment is that I had people put themselves in the shoes of the insurgency that's trying to kill American soldiers and I set it up so that at the end of the talk, people would have the opportunity to imagine what it would be like to be those guys and are they vicious, violent, terrorist killers or are they patriotic defenders? That's the question I asked the audience. So the talk went viral pretty quickly in the Middle East and I got an email from this guy and he's the first Iraqi who emailed me and before I started reading,
This is the start of the transcript. Save this video free for the whole transcript, searchable and time-coded.
In this course
Related notes
Summary, takeaways, and chapters were generated by AI from the video's transcript and may contain errors. The video belongs to its creator, SOC 119.