UTSA Life Insurance Finance Classes 20 and 21, Nov 3 and 5, 2026
Overview
The classes connect health insurance incentives with Michael E. Porter’s proposal to organize care around patient value, defined as outcomes relative to cost. They also survey disability, long-term care, and group life insurance before introducing mortality-table calculations and the pricing risks that distinguish insurance from ordinary products.
Key takeaways
- The proposed employer-benefit reform replaces $15,000 of employer health coverage with salary, taxes on $10,000, a $5,000 MSA contribution, and a $1,500 refundable tax credit intended to encourage insurance enrollment.
- Michael E. Porter defines healthcare value as patient outcomes relative to cost and proposes IPUs, outcome and cost measurement, bundled payments, integrated delivery, expanded reach, and shared data systems.
- Virginia Mason’s low-back-pain program cut MRI use by 23%, reduced missed workdays from 9 to 4.3, and increased annual new-patient volume from about 1,400 to 2,300 without adding staff or space.
- Disability policy definitions are decisive: own-occupation coverage protects a surgeon unable to operate, while any-occupation coverage may deny benefits if that surgeon can work in another job.
- Long-term care planning must account for costs that can greatly exceed public income support; the class example contrasts $1,800 monthly Social Security income with roughly $7,000 monthly assisted-living costs.
- Mortality-table timing matters in pricing: lx is measured at the beginning of the year, dx at year-end, and multi-year survival uses the ratio of survivor counts at the ending and starting ages.
Chapters
- The current system lets employers deduct health insurance premiums while employees generally receive employer-provided coverage tax-free.
- The resulting tax treatment encourages extensive use of insurance and reduces government tax revenue.
- The proposed alternative would replace employer-paid coverage with salary, an employee tax credit, and a medical savings account.
- In the illustrative case, an employer replaces $15,000 of health benefits with $15,000 in salary and avoids managing employee health plans.
- The employee pays tax on $10,000, contributes $5,000 to an MSA, and receives a $1,500 tax credit to help buy high-deductible insurance.
- Unused MSA funds accumulate, potentially helping cover future deductibles; the example assumes a $15,000 deductible.
- A refundable $1,500 credit makes buying insurance financially preferable to going uninsured and forfeiting the credit.
- Near-universal enrollment could reduce adverse selection by preventing a pool made up mainly of people who already expect high medical costs.
- The proposal aims to shift routine costs to consumers through high deductibles while retaining insurance for major expenses.
- Paying out of pocket could encourage patients to compare prices, question treatment, and seek lower-cost options, such as comparing MRI prices of $700 and $200.
- People with chronic conditions, insurers, healthcare providers, and wealthier consumers could lose under the proposed changes.
- Professor Sweet argues that concentrated losses can mobilize stronger opposition than broadly shared gains, citing Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky’s work on prospect theory.
- Porter’s central formula defines healthcare value as patient outcomes divided by the cost of achieving them.
- The strategy shifts care from a supply-driven system organized around providers to a patient-centered system organized around medical needs.
- The class identifies six components of Porter’s value agenda and notes that some overlap in the article’s diagram.
- Porter argues that access, cost reduction, and provider profitability are inadequate goals when pursued without regard to care quality.
- The relevant outcome is health improvement that matters to patients, measured against the cost required to achieve it.
- Fee-for-service rewards volume, while a value-based approach rewards better outcomes and efficiency.
- An integrated practice unit, or IPU, is a clinical and nonclinical team that provides the full care cycle for a patient’s condition.
- IPUs replace specialty silos with coordinated teams responsible for treatment, patient education, prevention, and follow-up.
- Team accountability is tied to maximizing overall patient outcomes efficiently, including support for behavior changes such as exercise and smoking cessation.
- Virginia Mason patients with low-back pain missed 4.3 workdays compared with 9 regionally and needed 4.4 physical therapy visits compared with 8.8.
- The clinic reduced MRI use for low-back pain by 23% and increased annual new-patient capacity from about 1,400 to 2,300 without adding space or staff.
- The example illustrates Porter’s claim that better coordination can improve outcomes, reduce waste, and increase provider productivity.
- Tier 1 measures health status achieved, including survival, functional ability, pain, and return to activity.
- Tier 2 measures the care process and recovery, including treatment delays, readmissions, discomfort, infections, and time back to work.
- Tier 3 measures durability, such as whether a hip replacement lasts 15 years rather than only two.
- Porter calls for measuring outcomes and costs for each patient and medical condition across the full care cycle.
- Many hospital accounting systems track departments and billing transactions rather than patient-level costs.
- Allocating staff, equipment, IT, administration, and facility costs to an individual patient requires difficult assumptions.
- Professor Sweet questions whether time-driven activity-based costing can reliably capture how clinicians and support departments divide their time.
- A $3 million medical device creates allocation questions about utilization, useful life, depreciation, and which patients should bear its cost.
- Virginia Mason’s example assigns approximate costs of $4 per minute for an orthopedic surgeon, $2 for an internist, and $1 for a nurse practitioner.
- Fee-for-service rewards additional procedures, while global capitation can reward cost cutting without necessarily rewarding better outcomes.
- Porter favors bundled payments for an acute condition’s full care cycle, a defined period of chronic care, or primary and preventive care for a population.
- Bundles should account for patient severity, avoidable complications, unusually high-cost cases, and mandatory outcome reporting.
- Walmart’s program directs employees needing certain cardiac, spine, and other surgeries to six selected high-volume providers.
- The bundled payment includes physician and hospital services before and after surgery; Walmart also covers travel, lodging, meals, and a caregiver.
- Porter’s model concentrates complex care where experience and volume can improve outcomes, while routine cases may be handled by lower-cost clinics.
- Porter’s IT foundation calls for patient-centered records accessible to everyone involved in care and systems that can extract useful data.
- Common data definitions are essential for coordination across providers; Professor Sweet notes that organizations may wait for Medicare to establish standards.
- The class recommends defining value and summarizing Porter’s six components in the paper, while treating some integration and geographic-reach components as overlapping.
- Disability insurance replaces income when injury or illness prevents work; it does not pay the medical bills covered by health insurance.
- Employer group coverage commonly includes short-term and long-term benefits, while workers’ compensation covers work-related injuries.
- Disability can be more likely than premature death during early working years, and recipients still need income for ordinary living expenses.
- Group coverage can reduce adverse selection because it covers a workforce rather than only people expecting a claim.
- Disability benefits should replace less than 100% of earnings so claimants retain a financial incentive to return to work.
- Policies may distinguish professional, white-collar, and blue-collar occupations, and may exclude work injuries already covered by workers’ compensation.
- Own-occupation coverage pays when a person cannot perform their specific job, such as a heart surgeon who can no longer operate.
- Less generous definitions may require inability to work in one’s trained field, inability to work after reasonable retraining, or inability to do any job.
- Buyers should inspect the policy’s definitions of disability, injury, and sickness, along with its waiting period and benefit amount.
- The class shows examples of disability fraud, including claimants who reported serious limitations while visibly performing activities they said they could not do.
- Disability benefits may affect labor-force participation statistics, although changing recognition of mental-health conditions may also explain rising claims.
- AFLAC is identified as a well-known insurer that offers disability coverage, and disability claims work is described as labor-intensive.
- Long-term care can involve home care or assisted living, and eligibility commonly depends on needing help with at least two activities of daily living.
- The example of Professor Sweet’s mother compares $1,800 in monthly Social Security income with assisted living costs of about $7,000 per month.
- Medicare coverage is limited, so households must weigh long-term care insurance against self-insuring with sufficient assets.
- Genworth is discussed as a major long-term care insurer facing a difficult market and substantial premium increases.
- Genetic testing can reveal elevated Alzheimer’s risk, creating adverse-selection concerns if customers know their risk but insurers cannot use the same information.
- The class raises the personal tradeoff of genetic testing: some people value advance planning, while others may regret learning a high-risk result.
- Accelerated benefits let a policyholder access life insurance proceeds early after a qualifying catastrophic or terminal illness.
- For a policy with a $140,000 death benefit, no cash value, and roughly $3,000 annual premiums, a viatical buyer estimated an offer near $45,000.
- Before surrendering a policy for zero cash value, compare keeping it in force with selling it through a viatical settlement.
- Employer group life insurance is often term coverage worth about one times salary, which may fall short of replacing an employee’s human capital.
- The employer holds a master contract, and group underwriting assesses the workforce rather than requiring individual medical evidence from every employee.
- Open enrollment helps insurers avoid adverse selection because employees choose coverage together rather than only after a health change.
- Group plans define eligible employee categories, benefit formulas, beneficiary rules, contribution arrangements, and when coverage ends.
- Insurers generally prefer noncontributory plans, where the employer pays the full premium, because employees cannot opt out based on individual health.
- A departing employee may convert group coverage to whole life, but high conversion mortality suggests converters are disproportionately likely to be unhealthy.
- Key-person insurance gives a business funds to manage the loss of an essential employee, including recruiting a replacement or sustaining operations.
- Corporate-owned, bank-owned, and trust-owned life insurance can direct death benefits to an organization and may be motivated by tax treatment.
- Professor Sweet warns that policy illustrations can overstate value if assumed mortality is too fast; his USAA example lost its projected tax advantage when mortality assumptions were revised.
- The class uses a simplified 1980 male mortality table beginning with 100,000 lives at age 25, while noting that newer tables extend to older ages.
- lx counts people alive at the beginning of an age-year, while dx counts deaths at the end of that year.
- px is the probability of surviving a year and qx is the probability of dying; the regulatory CSO table is conservative because it assumes faster mortality.
- The probability of surviving from age 25 to 35 is l35 divided by l25; the probability of dying over that interval is (l25 minus l35) divided by l25.
- In the example table, a 25-year-old has about a 75% chance of reaching age 65, based on 75,000 survivors out of 100,000.
- Median life expectancy is the age when half the original cohort remains; conditional life expectancy can rise for someone who has already survived to age 68.
- Unlike a bottle of Pepsi with a known production cost, an insurer cannot know its cost of goods sold when it sells a policy because future claims depend on mortality.
- Uncertain future claims increase business risk and required returns; in insurance and banking, capital generally refers to net worth rather than debt plus net worth.
- Term life carries substantial claim risk relative to its premiums, while whole life includes cash value; insurers use asset-liability management to coordinate mortality and investment risks.
Transcript excerpt
0:00 Our guest will be here next Thursday. So hopefully you'll have a really almost final draft your paper two. I don't know who he is, what he's going to say. It should be interesting. I'll talk try to talk to him a couple of days before so he has a good sense of what issues we've been hitting. I've given him some of them. He'll be on by Zoom. He's not going to come in in person because he's a couple hours away. All right. So really this is the last big issue to talk about. You can combine these two in the the same but make sure you understand this word tax credits. It's very important and how this is tied to the employer. So I I'll show you numerically so you can see you'll have to explain it in words. You don't have to agree with it but explain it. If you agree with it, you can talk
0:48 about why you agree with it. If you disagree with it, why you you don't like it. And then the last thing we have is porters. We'll go through borders tonight, maybe some in the Tuesday. I don't know. I have to have to stop a few minutes early just cuz it's it takes me a long time to walk back over because I have a a slight injury with my right leg. So, and I have a speaker tonight unless someone wants to piggyback me over there. All right. So, let's let's look at the tax side. So, just let's look at the current state. And I don't know if y'all have ever heard the term, see if I can find it in Wikipedia somewhere. It's a really good term. The economist use efficient.
1:38 Have you ever heard that before?
This is the start of the transcript. Save this video free for the whole transcript, searchable and time-coded.
In this course
Related notes
Summary, takeaways, and chapters were generated by AI from the video's transcript and may contain errors. The video belongs to its creator, Professor Sweet.