UTSA Life Insurance Finance Classes 18 and 19, Oct. 27 and 29, 2026
Overview
The class develops evidence and examples for a health care reform paper, arguing that fragmented data, weak consumer price information, fee-for-service incentives, and political barriers contribute to high costs and uneven quality. It examines AI, wearables, telemedicine, virtual wards, medical tourism, doctor shortages, overdiagnosis, and insurance design, while emphasizing that students should build a consistent policy argument and support it with current research.
Key takeaways
- Fragmented health records undermine AI's potential: shared, high-quality data could improve diagnosis and make useful discoveries available across hospitals more quickly.
- Virtual wards can move appropriate hospital care into the home; one cited program supported 75 patients with five nurses, a pharmacist, and two doctors while saving 7,900 bed-days annually.
- Medical tourism may produce extreme price differences, such as a cited Indian coronary bypass costing about $1,500 versus $106,000 at the Cleveland Clinic, but patients need dependable outcome data to compare quality.
- Payment incentives shape care: the lecture's examples of unnecessary stents, defensive testing, and wasted dialysis medication show how fee-for-service reimbursement can reward volume rather than improved health.
- Health policy arguments should be internally consistent: consumer-directed high-deductible care and universal public coverage require different financing and rationing assumptions, which a strong paper must make explicit.
- The class distinguishes prevention from medical treatment, emphasizing that exercise, diet, sleep, and smoking reduction can influence health even when health care billing systems primarily reward procedures and prescriptions.
Chapters
- The class reviews which subjects remain to be covered and notes that the paper should follow the course rubric.
- Students are encouraged to use the assigned articles, add recent research for their 10% outside-research component, and incorporate evidence from the assigned film.
- Wearables could move beyond exercise tracking to send vital-sign data to clinicians and flag potential problems early.
- The technology section can cover wearables, at-home diagnostics, telemedicine, virtual wards, and AI, while addressing health care regulation and patient safety.
- Amazon One Medical advertises on-demand virtual care, video visits, same-day or next-day appointments, and in-person locations.
- A five-hour physician wait followed by a brief chart review illustrates how conventional appointment systems can waste patient time.
- Students can investigate whether One Medical delivers more efficient service and whether technology companies can improve patient experience in a heavily regulated industry.
- Theranos illustrates the risks of applying a Silicon Valley 'move fast' approach to regulated diagnostics; general wellness products can face different scrutiny.
- Sesame Care offers cash-pay telehealth visits advertised at about $29 to $34, while One Medical offers virtual and in-person appointments through visits or subscriptions.
- Other examples include diabetes apps, diagnostic tools, and tech firms such as Apple, Amazon, and Alphabet entering health care.
- AI may help interpret medical images, predict patient outcomes, improve disease tracking, and accelerate drug discovery by analyzing large datasets.
- One cited skin-cancer detection comparison reported 86.6% accuracy for clinicians and 95% for the computer system.
- AI's consistency could spread a diagnostic improvement across hospitals faster than traditional publication and training, but fragmented records limit its usefulness.
- Health care AI adoption remains slow because of regulatory uncertainty, privacy concerns, fragmented records, and resistance to changing established workflows.
- AI could reduce administrative work, claims errors, and unnecessary treatment, but cost savings may threaten revenue tied to existing processes.
- The lecture argues that if payment systems reward more services rather than lower costs and better outcomes, innovation may increase spending instead of reducing it.
- Virtual wards differ from telemedicine: they let patients receive hospital-level monitoring at home using wearables, alerts, and occasional in-person checks.
- One cited program used five nurses, a pharmacist, and two doctors to care for 75 patients and reportedly saved 7,900 bed-days annually across 32 specialties.
- Home-based recovery may reduce exposure to hospital infections and shorten stays, although hospitals may have financial incentives to keep beds occupied.
- An Indian hospital model was presented as charging about $1,500 for a coronary bypass compared with roughly $106,000 at the Cleveland Clinic.
- The example attributes low costs partly to standardized, web-based logistics rather than building separate systems for each hospital.
- Students are advised to verify older medical-tourism figures and research whether lower prices correspond to comparable outcomes and quality.
- The paper should not advocate consumer-directed care with high deductibles and medical savings accounts while also endorsing unrestricted Medicare for all without reconciling the conflict.
- Students may present a preferred policy and then explain how an alternative could work under different assumptions.
- The instructor recommends addressing competing proposals explicitly rather than listing contradictory solutions as if they were compatible.
- The class cites Thailand as achieving 99.5% population coverage and life expectancy around 80 while spending roughly 6% of GDP on health care, compared with about 17% in the United States.
- The described system expanded medical infrastructure, sent medical graduates to rural areas for three years, and introduced public coverage schemes, including a focus on prevention.
- The example raises a central policy question: how can universal coverage remain affordable when government spending is controlled?
- A self-service walk-in clinic example used a computer intake system and provided prompt treatment for suspected walking pneumonia.
- Walmart had opened 32 health centers in the period covered by the cited material, combining services such as exams, dental care, laboratory work, and X-rays.
- Dollar General's partnership with DocGo ended, illustrating that retail health ventures can struggle even when they target convenient, lower-cost care.
- Examples include lower-cost dental care in Costa Rica, cardiology in India, and procedures in Turkey, Poland, Thailand, and Israel.
- The lecture cites large price differences, including a heart-valve replacement at about €35,000 in Germany versus €15,000 elsewhere, while warning that reliable comparative quality data is limited.
- Higher deductibles may encourage patients to compare prices and outcomes, and insurers could potentially help patients choose lower-cost international providers.
- The cited article says more than 100 million Americans live in areas with primary-care shortages and the United States has fewer than three physicians per 1,000 people.
- The lecture connects shortages to physician workload, retirements, pandemic-era burnout, and health care workers leaving jobs at elevated rates.
- U.S. medical training can take around 15 years, including medical school and a three-to-seven-year residency; the class asks whether every training year measurably improves care.
- Screening can find incidental abnormalities in people without symptoms, including gallstones, knee cartilage problems, and bulging spinal discs.
- A cited mammography example estimated that screening 2,000 women might prevent one death while causing false alarms and unnecessary procedures for many others.
- The lecture contrasts medical treatment with prevention: exercise, diet, sleep, and smoking reduction can address major health risks, yet billing systems contain thousands of procedure codes and few incentives for keeping people healthy.
- Sample papers follow the rubric's sequence of problem, incentives, and solutions, using charts, focused quotations, and clear explanations of abbreviations.
- An abstract should quickly tell a reader what the paper covers; a two-column layout and centered italicized quotations are optional presentation choices.
- A focused outside-research topic such as One Medical can satisfy the 10% research component, and the instructor accepts useful website links as references.
- Students should briefly acknowledge that malpractice concerns may lead physicians to order extra tests as defensive medicine.
- The assigned material describes defensive testing as one contributor to costs, but the instructor characterizes it as a modest factor rather than a primary explanation for high spending.
- The book discussed is Overcharged: Why Americans Pay Too Much for Health Care, by Charles Silver and David Hyman, associated with the Cato Institute.
- Its central critique is that political control and excessive insurance make prices opaque and weaken consumers' ability to compare providers.
- The book's extensive bibliography is presented as a useful source for additional evidence and citations, while students are cautioned to account for its libertarian perspective.
- The lecture contrasts value-based pharmaceutical pricing with competitive pricing based on marginal cost, arguing that competition can allow consumers to capture more of a drug's value.
- It notes that public grants fund some pharmaceutical research and development, complicating claims that high prices simply reflect companies' research costs.
- A cited example says Medicare paid physicians more for a costlier eye treatment even though randomized trials found the alternatives largely equivalent.
- One cited study estimated that two-thirds of elective stent procedures, about 200,000 cases, were unnecessary and provided no demonstrated reduction in death or nonfatal heart attacks.
- The estimated annual cost of those procedures was $2.4 billion before including associated drugs and monitoring.
- The class also discusses doctors who performed highly profitable cardiac procedures on 750 patients, allegedly causing 94 deaths, as an example of how incentives can become outright fraud.
- The lecture cites reviews finding no evidence that routine mammography screening reduced overall mortality across more than 600,000 women, while acknowledging that individual lives may be saved and others harmed.
- It argues that early, weaker studies can create established treatment practices that are difficult to reverse when later research changes the evidence.
- Examples include back surgery and arthroscopic knee procedures that may offer no better results than nonsurgical treatment, despite hundreds of thousands of annual operations.
- The book reports large political contributions from pharmaceutical firms, hospitals, and physicians, and presents lobbying as a force shaping health policy.
- A cited estimate puts unnecessary care at about 30% of health spending, with approximately $1 trillion in annual waste.
- The class emphasizes comparing policy alternatives: spending on medical treatment can displace other health-related investments such as exercise, diet, sleep, and pollution reduction.
- Out-of-network clinicians can bill patients using high chargemaster prices when they have not accepted the insurer's negotiated discount; federal legislation addressed some surprise-billing situations.
- The book cites patients at the worst hospitals as three times more likely to die and 13 times more likely to experience complications than patients at the best hospitals.
- Patients need comparable quality data, such as hospital error rates for prostate surgery, because price alone may not indicate quality.
- Medicare and Medicaid process about 3 billion claims annually; reviewing each for five minutes would require roughly 125,000 people working 2,000 hours.
- The lecture argues that automated data analysis could help flag suspicious claims, while recounting a case in which a whistleblower identified billing for nonexistent patients.
- It also describes a dialysis drug billing example in which providers wasted medication to bill for full vials, then changed behavior after reimbursement shifted to a flat treatment rate.
- A cited Medicaid study found that newly covered participants used about 35% more medical services and 40% more emergency-room visits, with only modest measured health differences.
- The lecture uses this finding to discuss how insurance affects demand for care, while cautioning that the comparison does not establish that all additional use is unnecessary.
- A chart in the material associates higher out-of-pocket shares with lower health spending, though the class notes that correlation alone does not prove causation.
- The Affordable Care Act limits how much insurers may charge older adults relative to younger adults, despite the lecture's cited estimate that their underlying costs can differ by about six to one.
- The class frames this as a transfer from younger to older policyholders and discusses the individual mandate as a mechanism for keeping healthier people in the insurance pool.
- A quotation attributed to health economist Jonathan Gruber says that explicitly describing the transfer from healthy people to sick people could have made the law harder to pass.
- The class asks students to compare the uninsured rate before and after the ACA, citing a current figure around 11% and describing the decline as substantial.
- Open enrollment through HealthCare.gov gives people a route to obtain coverage without medical underwriting, including those with ongoing health concerns.
- Employer group coverage spreads risk across healthy and sick workers; the instructor proposes tax credits as a possible way to extend risk pooling beyond employers.
- Without broad participation, healthier people may leave while people with greater health needs remain, increasing premiums and prompting further departures.
- The class presents mandates as one way to keep a mix of healthy and sick people in the insurance pool, while identifying tax credits as a possible alternative worth examining.
- Students are asked to acknowledge people with serious ongoing conditions who lack coverage and assess how open enrollment and employer-based insurance address the problem.
- The remaining paper topics are expected to be completed in the next class, with pre-existing conditions and tax credits discussed together.
- Students are reminded to finish the final sections and summarize the relevant assigned article with a clear, consistent argument.
Transcript excerpt
0:00 So, I'll be working on I'll probably set the day. I think we're getting to the point where your paper is so far along that he could come in as early as Thursday of next week, but we'll see. I'll talk to him. So, hopefully he's pretty radical and give you different type of view. And I'll warn him on the PBS special and I've sent them up previous students. Oh, I told you I was showing you all paper. Forgot about that. Hopefully I'll remember to do that on Thursday. I did send him a former student's paper to see. So, I've marked what we haven't covered yet and it's actually not that much. On On this one we'll just talk that one really quick. Some of this stuff you just need to look it up real quickly cuz we don't really have an article on it. We'll definitely talk about this one, pretty easy one, and then there's a couple of them here
0:47 where you just need to look it up. I don't think it's in the articles, but it's pretty easy to find. I gave you an article on this one, so it's just a matter of going back and pulling stuff from that. So, I just need to reference you to that article. We didn't We hinted at this one. I want to do a little bit of math. These two are tied together. We We've had articles and discussions about this. So, I think the second article actually talked about untying health care to the employer. I just think putting quotes in there. Tonight, hopefully we'll get into the tech side. We won't go through all of the articles, but I'll show you what and a huge part of this one will make sure you're having
This is the start of the transcript. Save this video free for the whole transcript, searchable and time-coded.
In this course
Related notes
Summary, takeaways, and chapters were generated by AI from the video's transcript and may contain errors. The video belongs to its creator, Professor Sweet.